In Dreamworks’ defense, they’ve actually been doing pretty good lately, so long as you ignore the Shrek series.
‘Bee Movie’, ‘Kung-Fu Panda’ and ‘How to Train Your Dragon’ were all pretty great movies. (Especially ‘Dragon’, which was one of the best movies I’ve seen so far this year.)
The only problem Dreamworks has is that it occasionally takes a pretty good movie, and sucks the life out of it by trying to make a sequel (‘Shrek’, obviously, and also ‘Madagascar’).
Pixar even took a risk making Toy Story 2, and I was surprised (and even a little disappointed) when I first heard they were going to make 3. This a company which has a pretty strict ‘No Sequel’ rule, so to take the company’s crown-jewel and risk it’s integrity with two follow-ups is pretty ballsy.
Chaim Mattis Keller said, on June 21, 2010 at 5:38 pm
Cars 2 is in the making, so I have a feeling that their resistance to sequels is gone – at least when it comes to sequels that are very merchandiseable.
@Jake: I believe Pixar’s policy was strict no straight-to-dvd features.
IIRC, Disney proposed making Toy Story 2 as a straight-to-dvd, and Pixar said they will only do a sequel if they think it can hold up to its predecessor. And so they did, and it seems they did it again now.
Toy Story 3 was even better than ‘Up’. I make this distinction because I was actually able to see the screen after fifteen minutes instead of the animators’ hard work being lost in a blur of tears.
The blur of tears comes fairly late in Toy Story 2, during “Jesse’s Song.” I haven’t yet seen Toy Story 3, but I will be reduced to tears if there isn’t a blur of tears scene.
To be fair, I found myself as pleasantly surprised by Shrek 4 as I had been by Shrek 2.
The 3D branch of Disney Animation is doing a superb job on its own, too. Meet The Robinsons, Chicken Little, Bolt, all have been excellent films, and each felt like Disney. I’m looking forward to their Rapunzel, “Tangled.”
Hysterical Woman said, on June 23, 2010 at 2:00 am
Shark Tale was the worse. That fish’s design was less anthropomorphic and more “omg it stole Will Smith’s face”. To be fair I’ve never seen that movie.
Amazon #1 New Release: Cat, Dog & Animal Humor! Amazon #1 New Release: Humorous Verse
#1 New York Times    #2 Indie Bestseller 2013 NPR/IndieBound Bestseller L.A. Times Bestseller S.F.Chronicle Bestseller Denver Post Bestseller Seattle Times Bestseller Boston Globe Bestseller Amazon Top 100 Bestseller Barnes & Noble Top 100
NPR/IndieBound Bestseller L.A. Times Bestseller S.F.Chronicle Bestseller Denver Post Bestseller Boston Globe Bestseller
Also, what is this thing called “Not overstaying one’s welcome”?
In Dreamworks’ defense, they’ve actually been doing pretty good lately, so long as you ignore the Shrek series.
‘Bee Movie’, ‘Kung-Fu Panda’ and ‘How to Train Your Dragon’ were all pretty great movies. (Especially ‘Dragon’, which was one of the best movies I’ve seen so far this year.)
The only problem Dreamworks has is that it occasionally takes a pretty good movie, and sucks the life out of it by trying to make a sequel (‘Shrek’, obviously, and also ‘Madagascar’).
Pixar even took a risk making Toy Story 2, and I was surprised (and even a little disappointed) when I first heard they were going to make 3. This a company which has a pretty strict ‘No Sequel’ rule, so to take the company’s crown-jewel and risk it’s integrity with two follow-ups is pretty ballsy.
Cars 2 is in the making, so I have a feeling that their resistance to sequels is gone – at least when it comes to sequels that are very merchandiseable.
Monsters, Inc 2 is also coming out.
They’ve always said that they would do sequels if they had a strong enough story, and looking at Toy Story 3 I have to believe them.
@Jake: I believe Pixar’s policy was strict no straight-to-dvd features.
IIRC, Disney proposed making Toy Story 2 as a straight-to-dvd, and Pixar said they will only do a sequel if they think it can hold up to its predecessor. And so they did, and it seems they did it again now.
Toy Story 3 was even better than ‘Up’. I make this distinction because I was actually able to see the screen after fifteen minutes instead of the animators’ hard work being lost in a blur of tears.
The blur of tears comes fairly late in Toy Story 2, during “Jesse’s Song.” I haven’t yet seen Toy Story 3, but I will be reduced to tears if there isn’t a blur of tears scene.
Wait… that might work!
Don’t look forward to being able to read the credits of 3. It can’t be done.
Yup, the ending of Toy Story 3 will completely gut you. Wonderful movie, wonderful trilogy.
Oh, the blur is there, for sure.
And the 3d short, “Day and Night” is pretty darned good too. Artistic and entertaining.
To be fair, I found myself as pleasantly surprised by Shrek 4 as I had been by Shrek 2.
The 3D branch of Disney Animation is doing a superb job on its own, too. Meet The Robinsons, Chicken Little, Bolt, all have been excellent films, and each felt like Disney. I’m looking forward to their Rapunzel, “Tangled.”
The best part of this comic is Shrek doing the “Dreamworks face”
Shark Tale was the worse. That fish’s design was less anthropomorphic and more “omg it stole Will Smith’s face”. To be fair I’ve never seen that movie.
If only there was a second Incredibles. That was an awesome movie.
If only Pixar had done the Fantastic Four movies! Now, that would have been awesome.
In its defense, I thought I was going to hate “Shrek 4” but ended up liking it better than any of the other Shrek movies.